Mama J's Pizza

Enjoy a sub and salad from them, worth stopping and checking out

Great all around. The sides are fantastic. Tater tots breaded mushrooms, fried pickle chips. You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. The pizza is fantastic when it's cooked enough. I'm going to start asking for well done because when it's done right it's amazing. Extra cheese just makes everything better. Mama J's recently just started getting ice cream. So far I've only tried the hard dip cookie dough and I hated it, but possible that that's just a personal preference. My wife tried a banana split of sorts and said she enjoyed it but it wasn't as good as something as like the creamery in Delphos Ohio. I'll update this review if I try the ice cream again.

I would argue to say it's the best pizza joint in Wapakoneta. Ordering online is awesome for such a small business and they have delivery. What more could you ask for.

Edit: they've added so much new food and all of it is amazing. The only thing that is subpar is the ice cream. I've had better ice cream from Walmart

I just moved to the Uniopolis, Wapakoneta area and decided to try it out. We ordered a 12" pepperoni pizza, Bosco cheesy sticks, bbq boneless wings, and loaded tatter tots.

The pizza was decent. The cheese was a crispy perfect texture. If you like extra cheese, this is for you. As far as the dough and the sauce, I did not personally like. Dough was to soft almost underbaked in a sense, and the pizza sauce was a little extra. Pizza I give a 6/10.

The Bosco sticks were awesome! Perfectly glazed, cooked perfectly, cheesy stuffed was just the right temp. 9/10 buy these you won't regret it!

BBQ wings were very saucy. The BBQ was sweet and the chicken was a bit soft. Overall I give it a 7/10. Ill update this when I try the buffalo sauce (yes I will be buying from this place again!!)

The loaded tater tots were the best thing here. I got them fully loaded and I haven't had tater tots since high school so I was happy to try them... They are better than I remember!!! 10/10!!!

To recap: I would 100% buy from here again (and soon!) I just wouldn't buy the pizza again. My wife did enjoy it to be noted. I was more than stuffed with the tots, wings, AND bread sticks! Overall I give this place a 9/10! A rare small town find! Yes! 💎

Fantastic food for a great price! Whether you get delivery or pick-up, Mama J's is the place to get pizza, subs, salads and even some sweets! Order online at mamajspizza.com and your food will be ready in no time!