Papa Giorgios

We chose this restaurant because of the great reviews, and the reviews were right. Absolutely delicious pizza! The house favorite was our favorite. Even though it seems to be mostly carry out, (there are only a couple of tables inside) we chose to dine in, and thoroughly enjoyed our experience. The staff was very friendly and attentive. We even chatted with the owner, who was very nice! We will definitely be back!

We have never had a bad bite from Papa Giorgios! It's been a firm household favorite since our first visit. I always get a cheese pizza; a boring choice perhaps, but there's nowhere to hide either. Luckily there's nothing to hide here: every element--crust, cheese, sauce--is delicious and in perfect proportion. My better half can't seem to quit the Italian sub, but the few times he's torn himself away from that menu item he has enjoyed the detour. The house-made crust and bread are particularly worthy of praise, elevating every menu item that uses them (which is a lot). Definitely check this place out!

I live two counties away and every time I within 5 miles of Papa Giorgio's I make it a point to stop. Wonderful NY style pizza, this visit I brought a buddy and now he's hooked too. Great pizza! The atmosphere question is pretty funny, it's a hole in the wall pizza shop with extremely limited space so we appreciate the few tables they have since it appears 95% of their business is takeout.

Ordered a Supreme without olives and was pleased. East coast style thin crust pie with a bit of flop to it but comes together nicely. Great sauce and good service. Solid game day choice.

Wow the house favorite pizza is so good! I use to go to a small place in my hometown called Pizza Chef and order a pizza just like the house favorite. I’m so happy I discovered this place and will be ordering from here more often.